It’s been a tumultuous past few years for employers and employees alike. From COVID-19, the Great Resignation of 2021, and workplace buzzwords such as quiet quitting, quiet hiring, and work-life balance which are difficult contentions to talk about. At the start of 2023, there’s a new buzzword taking over the workplace called “quiet hiring”.
In all honesty, the concept of quiet hiring isn’t entirely new, in comparison with quiet quitting and quiet firing. All these concepts had been around for a while, the contention is that now that the workforce is primarily being occupied by younger generations of workers, such as Millennials and the Generation Z, because of this we’ll see more workplace buzzwords going around social media, as they are more akin to vent out their frustrations and dissatisfactions online.
What Is Quite Hiring?
Quiet hiring can be defined as a recruitment strategy that involves filling open positions quickly and discreetly, without attracting a large number of applicants or drawing attention to the company’s hiring process. Basically, quiet hiring can be used for high-level executive positions or for positions that the company wants to fill quickly and quietly, such as when a key employee is leaving suddenly.
As the trend perpetuates throughout the workplace, several factors comes into play, which will or will not benefit the company. Those factors are a faster hiring process, sourcing a candidate suitable to the established company culture, cost savings, and a few other negative factors such as limited pool of applicants, perpetuating bias, lack of transparency, and may result in a negative perception among current employees and the public.
From a worker’s perspective, quiet hiring also has positive and even negative aspects. Some positive effects include job security and career advancement opportunities. On the flip side, there would be limited opportunities for external candidates and lack of transparency might perpetuate negative perceptions about the company.
The Pros And Cons Of Quiet Hiring
Pros of quiet hiring:
- Selectivity: Quiet hiring allows companies to be more selective in their recruitment process. By not making a public announcement, companies can avoid a flood of resumes from unqualified candidates and instead focus on reaching out to a select group of individuals who are a good fit for the position.
- Fill vacant positions quickly: Quiet hiring can help companies fill positions that are hard to fill through traditional means. For example, if a company is looking to fill a niche role, it may be difficult to find the right candidate through job postings or recruiting events. Quiet hiring allows companies to reach out to potential candidates directly, increasing the chances of finding a qualified candidate.
- Confidentiality: Quiet hiring allows companies to keep their plans for growth and expansion private. This can be especially important for startups or companies in highly competitive industries. By not making a public announcement, companies can avoid attracting unwanted attention from competitors and keep their plans for growth and expansion under wraps.
Cons of quiet hiring:
- Limited candidate pool: Quiet hiring limits the pool of candidates that a company can reach out to. As companies are not making a public announcement, they might not be able to reach a wide range of potential candidates.
- Lack of transparency: Quiet hiring can be perceived as secretive and that lack of transparency can be detrimental to the company’s reputation.
- Limited company awareness: Quiet hiring can also limit awareness of the company among potential candidates. When a company is not making a public announcement, potential candidates might not be aware of job opportunities that are available, which can make it difficult to attract top talent.
- Legal and compliance issues: Quiet hiring can also raise legal and compliance issues. For example, if a company is not making a public announcement, it might not be able to demonstrate compliance with anti-discrimination laws.
- Risk of negative impact on employee morale: When employees learn that a colleague was quietly hired, it can lead to negative impact on employee morale and may lead to mistrust and resentment. Due to the fact that they missed the opportunity to advance their positions within the company.
The Bottom Line
All that is said, quiet hiring is a recruitment strategy that can be highly effective in certain situations, but it should be approached with caution. The main advantages of quiet hiring include selectivity, the ability to fill hard-to-fill positions, and the ability to keep plans for growth and expansion private. However, it also has several disadvantages, such as a limited candidate pool, lack of transparency, and compliance issues.
Companies should carefully weigh the pros and cons before deciding to implement quiet hiring, and be prepared to handle the added level of confidentiality and discretion that comes with it. Additionally, it’s important to consider the potential impact on employee morale and take steps to mitigate any negative effects. Overall, quiet hiring can be a valuable tool in the recruitment process, but it should be used judiciously and with a clear understanding of the potential risks and benefits.